Mistletoad

The Mistletoad is not a sell-multiplier you stamp on a fruit but a limited Mythical pet introduced during the Christmas Harvest Event, and that distinction matters for how you value it. It came exclusively from Santa's Surprise Present at a 2.5% hatch chance, which makes it a genuinely scarce collectible rather than a farmable mutation.

Because it is a pet, its worth is tied to whatever passive ability it carries and to its event-locked rarity, not to a flat number you can chain onto crops. A 2.5% pull rate means most players opened many presents without seeing one, so the surviving population is small and demand stays steady among collectors who missed the window.

Is it worth chasing now? Since the Christmas Harvest Event has ended, the Mistletoad can no longer be obtained directly — your only routes are trading or having banked one during the event. For value, treat it as a long-hold trophy: limited Mythicals from past holidays tend to hold or climb in trade weight as supply stays frozen, so keep yours rather than dumping it for a quick crop-mutation grind.