Grow a Garden · Crops
Rotten Apple
Grow a Garden · Crops · Rarity: Divine
About Rotten Apple
The Rotten Apple is a divine crop that was added to the third part of the Halloween Event 2026 (October 31, 2026). It can be obtained from the Headless Horseman Rewards with a 1% chance.
Rotten Apple — In-Depth Analysis
Rotten Apple has the lowest chance of any line in the Headless Horseman reward table: 1%, or one seed per hundred rewards on paper. The next rarest line, three Haunted Chests, is listed at 2.7%. The wiki rates the crop Divine, marks it as multi-harvest and says it arrived on October 31, 2026, in the third part of the Halloween Event 2026.
To reach that table, a player has to chase the Headless Horseman, who loses his head every 30 minutes. The head must be carried back within 2 minutes, before it despawns, and other players can hit the carrier with a shovel to make it drop. Once it is returned, the NPC rides across the map for 2 minutes dropping blue wisps, and collecting 50 of them lets the player choose a reward. The wiki also lists a 49 Robux option that skips the wisps and gives the reward at once.
Its categories are Fruit, Leafy, Night, Sour, Spooky, Toxic and Woody type crops. The appearance section of the wiki is still unwritten. The Rotten Apple is not in the Scary Seeds table and no Black Cat set asks for it.