Pumpkin Pufferfish

Frightful Village once offered the Pumpkin Pufferfish, a Limited fish that the description sums up as a pufferfish with a spooky twist. It is flagged Unobtainable, so today there is no way to catch one.

While it lasted, the catch conditions were specific: Hallow-Pop as bait, Night, and Autumn. The data records an average value of C$200 and 150 base XP, with no weight range, which suggests a small payout. Among the 742 documented fish it ranks 486th by average value, firmly in the lower half. That fits a seasonal novelty better than a serious earner.

The same zone and rarity hold Candle Carp, Coffin Crab, Ectoplasm Eel, Frankenshrimp, Frightful Crate and Gravestone Stingray, which gives a sense of how many Limited catches Frightful Village carried.

If you have one in your inventory, the decision is easy. It is worth little, so it only makes sense to keep it as a souvenir of the event, and nothing is lost by selling it if you need the C$200. If you never got one, you missed a low-value item, not a major prize, so do not feel bad about it. Put your effort into fish you can still reach.