2nd Anniversary

2nd Anniversary is kept on the site as a reference entry: the wiki lists it as no longer accessible, tagged both Seasonal Event and Unobtainable, so none of what follows is advice on where to fish. The record documents 12 fish, every one of them Limited, with no caption and no NPC inhabitants. Because all entries share the Limited rarity, there is no rarity spread to compare; the differences are all in value.

The value table is steep at the top. Birthday Profane Leviathan is listed at an average of C$57,143 and Birthday Leviathan at C$42,928, a gap of C$14,215 between the two. 2nd Birthday Balloon follows at C$10,333, then Birthday Colossal Squid at C$7,125 and Birthday Isonade at C$6,577. The other seven names are Birthday Candle, Birthday Card, Birthday Cupcake, Birthday Floppy, Birthday Pinata, Birthday Present and Birthday Rubber Ducky.

Verdict: use this page to look up what the anniversary event contained and what its top fish were worth; with the event ended, it works as a historical record rather than a guide to obtaining them.