Fisch location
Carrot Garden

Fish here
8
Top avg. value
C$12,457
Carrot Turtle
NPCs
1
Rods here
0
Fish at Carrot Garden
| Carrot Goldfish | Common | C$33 | — | — | Clear | Spring |
| Carrot Pufferfish | Common | C$36 | — | — | Rain | Spring |
| Carrot Eel | Uncommon | — | — | — | Windy | Spring |
| Carrot Minnow | Uncommon | C$73 | — | — | Foggy | Spring |
| Carrot Salmon | Rare | C$236 | — | — | Clear | Spring |
| Carrot Turtle | Legendary | C$12,457 | — | — | Clear | Spring |
| Carrot Snapper | Mythical | C$2,291 | — | — | Foggy | Spring |
| Carrot Shark | Exotic | C$3,565 | — | — | Windy | Spring |
8 rows · click a column to sort
Carrot Garden guide
In Carrot Garden the most valuable fish is not the rarest one. Carrot Turtle, a Legendary, averages C$12,457, which beats the Exotic Carrot Shark at C$3,565 and the Mythical Carrot Snapper at C$2,291. If you read rarity labels as a price guide, this zone is a good reminder to check the numbers.
Seven fish are documented here: one Legendary, one Exotic, one Mythical, one Rare, one Uncommon and two Common. After the top three the list drops quickly, with Carrot Salmon (Rare) at C$236 and Carrot Minnow (Uncommon) at C$73.3. Carrot Pufferfish, Carrot Goldfish, Carrot Eel and the remaining carrot-themed species fill out the zone.
The only inhabitants recorded are the Carrot Gremlins. There is no crab cage, no bait crate and no rod sold on site, so everything you need must come with you.
Practical advice: treat Carrot Turtle as the reason to come. It is worth roughly three and a half times the Carrot Shark, so a single lucky catch can pay for the whole trip. Everything below the Snapper is ordinary sale fodder. Players with a decent rod and no interest in grinding will get more out of a short visit than a long one.
NPCs
- Carrot Gremlins
Data sourced from the Fisch Wiki (CC BY-SA) and processed automatically; not tested in the game; last synced 2026-10-21.